ACSVAW Outlines Five Key Concerns Regarding the "Sexual Offences Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2026"
The Association Concerning Sexual Violence Against Women (ACSVAW) welcomes the government's introduction of the Sexual Offences Legislation (Amendment) Bill 2026 (the Bill) to the Legislative Council. We are pleased to see the current administration utilising its remaining term to implement sexual offence reforms that have been two decades in the making. While we appreciate that the Bill incorporates several of our recommendations, including the introduction of new offences addressing persistent child sexual abuse, there remains crucial room for improvement to ensure the reforms genuinely reflect and improve the lived realities of victim-survivors.
To achieve the intended impact of these reforms, ACSVAW urges the authorities to address the following five critical areas during the legislative process:
1. The High Risk of "Mistaken Belief" Remaining Vulnerable to Exploitation
While the Secretary for Security noted earlier in the Legislative Council’s Panel on Security that the accused should have a positive duty to ascertain consent, such determination is not reflected in the Bill drafted where it places no statutory limits on the "mistaken belief" defence.¹ To prevent the courts from interpreting this loosely, we advocate for the Bill to mandate two safeguards:
No "mistaken belief" defence when the 11 non-consent circumstances apply: If a scenario involves a clear absence of consent (e.g., the victim is unconscious due to intoxication, threatened with violence, or deceived), the accused must be entirely barred from using a "mistaken belief in consent" as a defence.
Steps taken to ascertain consent as a mandatory consideration in determining the reasonableness of mistaken belief: When determining if a mistaken belief was reasonable, the court must be required to consider what the accused actually said or did to ascertain consent. An inference, or the act of pressuring and testing boundaries, cannot be treated as having ascertained consent.
2. Clarifying That the Expanded Offence of "Rape" Covers All Forms of Oral Sexual Assaults
The Law Reform Commission of Hong Kong previously recommended modelling the expanded offence of "rape" on Western Australia's "sexual penetration without consent," which encompasses both cunnilingus and fellatio,² and adapting this by suitable drafting. Unfortunately, the current Bill's definition of the expanded offence only covers penetration of the mouth with the penis. We strongly advocate revising this to include other forms of oral sexual assaults, such as the application of the mouth or tongue to the genitalia or anus. This ensures the law provides equal deterrence and protection against all forms of oral sexual assaults
3. Retaining the Term "Rape (‘強姦’)" Hinders the Immediate Impact of Reform
As survivors and ACSVAW have consistently advocated, renaming the offence to "sexual penetration without consent" is vital. The retained term "rape"—and particularly its Chinese equivalent, "強姦"—carries a severe, gendered stigma that deters many victim-survivors from seeking help. Furthermore, retaining the old terminology creates a technical dilemma for public understanding. The simultaneous application of "new rape" and "old rape" in different trials over the coming decades will project an inconsistent image of the reform's implementation. Updating the legal terminology is the most immediate and effective way to advance legal and gender education locally, reinforcing the principle of sexual autonomy.
ACSVAW is pleased to note that the Bill proposes introducing a new offence of "maintaining persistently abusive sexual relationship with child under 16" to address existing loopholes in prosecuting persistent child sexual abuse. Drawing on the experiences of local survivors as well as overseas jurisdictions, we believe there is room to further strengthen the proposed provisions in the following areas:
4. Clarifying the Retrospective Application of the New "Persistent Child Sexual Abuse" Offence
The creation of a new persistent child sexual abuse offence aims to close existing prosecutorial loopholes. ACSVAW urges the government to clarify the retrospective effect of this offence, ensuring it applies to historical offending that were already illegal at the time they were committed. Regarding sentencing, Hong Kong should look to overseas jurisdictions: if the prosecution brings charges retrospectively, the court should use the maximum penalty applicable at the time the offence occurred as the sentencing reference.
5. Lowering the Incident Threshold for "Persistent Child Sexual Abuse" to Two Acts
The Bill currently requires particularisation of three or more abusive sexual acts against the victim to establish a "persistently abusive sexual relationship". In the early 2000s, the Department of Justice originally suggested a three-act threshold based on New South Wales law. NSW, however, has amended this requirement to two acts in 2018. Other jurisdictions that have reviewed and refined this offence, including Queensland (2003), South Australia (2008), and the Australian Capital Territory (2017), have also lowered the required number of incidents to reflect a resolute commitment to addressing the realities of child sexual abuse. To genuinely accommodate the difficulties survivors face in recalling the precise details of every single incident, the government should learn from the reform experiences from other jurisdictions and improve the threshold to two acts.
¹ The Bill states that an accused person does not commit an offence if they "reasonably believe that the subject individual consents to the penetration," and that "in determining whether a person's belief was reasonable, regard is to be had to all the facts and circumstances of the case, including any steps the person had taken to ascertain whether the subject individual consented to the relevant act."
² Western Australia's 2023 law reform review pointed out that "non-consensual, non-penetrative acts of oral sex are just as wrongful, and potentially harmful, as non-consensual, penetrative sexual acts. They constitute an equally serious, highly intrusive invasion of a person's sexual autonomy and bodily integrity". It therefore recommended revising the definition concerning oral sex acts more explicitly to: "The application of the mouth or tongue to the genitalia or anus, regardless of whether there is any penetration".